
Ever since I saw her on American Idol, I've been a big Carrie Underwood fan so I've been eagerly anticipating the release of her third album. I love
Some Hearts but will admit that I was a little disappointed with
Carnival Ride. There were some songs on it that I loved but probably only 5 or 6. I thought that since I posted about getting
Play On that it would be fitting to let you know what I think.
So here's a play by play.
#1- Cowboy Casanova- I love this song. It reminds me a lot of Before He Cheats with the big voice and upbeat tempo. And it's a lot of fun to sing. 5 out of 5 stars.
#2- Quitter - The beginning of this song reminds me of a "Boys Are Better Than Girls" song that my sister-in-law made at Disney Quest, which makes me smile. It's a fun upbeat number that's pretty catchy. 3 out of 5 stars.
#3- Mama's Song- I really like this song about a girl telling her mom that she's found someone else to take care of her and that he'll take good care of her. It reminds me a lot of
Don't Forget to Remember Me but Carrie's vocals are amazing. 4 out of 5 stars.
#4- Change - I've read a bunch of reviews that call this song cliche and "the next Idol Gives Back theme song," but I love it. A song about a small thing making all the difference and amazing vocals make it one of my favorites on the album. 5 out of 5 stars.
#5- Undo It - Another upbeat one with fun vocals. Probably my 2nd favorite upbeat song after Cowboy Casanova. 4 out of 5 stars.
#6- Someday When I Stop Loving You - This song is my least favorite out of the first eight, but I still like it. A slow ballad with good vocals and a beautiful chorus. 3 out of 5 stars.
#7- Songs Like This - A catchy upbeat song with good chorus (and it's a lot of fun to sing); another Carrie revenge song that is addicting. 3 out of stars.
#8 - Temporary Home - This song reminds me why I love country music. Stories, beautiful singing, and a great message. 5 out of 5 stars.
#9 - This Time - This upbeat ballad is just okay for me and kind of forgettable. I had to listen to it four times before I really remembered it at all. 3 out of 5 stars for good vocals.
#10- Look At Me - This song reminded me a lot of the last half of Carnival Ride that I skip over pretty much every time I listen to it. I'm not a huge fan of real slow ballads, and yes Carrie sings it well, but similiar to
I Told You So, I just get bored. 2 out of 5 stars for good vocals.
#11- Unapologize - A song about a girl who tells someone about her feelings, apologizes for those feelings, then decides to unapologize for what she says. Not particularly catchy or memorable although the more I listen to it, it's growing on me. 3 out of 5 stars.
#12 - What Can I Say - This could be one of my favorite Carrie songs ever. A duet with Sons of Sylvia (who I didn't know before but am going to look up now), their voices blend together to create a beautiful sound. 5 out of 5 stars.
#13- Play On - My least favorite out of all of the upbeat songs, this just isn't memorable to me at all. Another song about pushing (or playing) on when you get to the end or hit difficulty. The idea reminded me of
The Climb, but it's nowhere near as catchy or powerful. 2 out of 5 stars.
My Least Favorites:- Play On
- Unapologize
- Look At Me
My Favorites:- Change
- Temporary Home
- What Can I Say
Overall album rating - 4 out of 5 stars